E-Bikes

Electric bicycles have evolved into practical tools for transportation and recreation. They make it possible to continue cycling despite injury or the reality that our ability to generate power declines over time. As noted in this NYT article (Over the Alps on a Bike With a Boost) riders who are not quite as strong can still enjoy longer rides, multi-day tours, or riding with stronger partners.

Many traditional cyclists worry that electric assist will reduce training benefits or cardiovascular fitness. In reality, a pedal-assist e-bike, especially modern systems with adjustable assist levels, can provide substantial exercise. One way to view electric assist is as a built-in tailwind or paceline, both of which cyclists routinely use to reduce effort and ride farther.

Choosing an E-Bike

There are three classes of e-bikes.

Most new e-bike riders initially overestimate both the motor size and battery capacity they actually need.

Motors are rated in watts - the maximum power they can provide. For typical short distance recreational riding, even modest assist levels provide substantial benefit. This article is a nice summary of the question and concludes the average urban cyclist only needs a 250 watt motor.

The motor system is the heart of the bike and long-term reliability matters. If you have a choice, stay with one of the major motor manufacturers - Bosch, Yamaha, Shimano or Brose. This is a nice review of e-bike motors circa 2022.

Battery capacity is rated in watt-hours (Wh), a measure of total energy stored in the battery. Higher Wh ratings generally mean longer range but also a heavier battery and bike. Common recreational e-bike batteries are rated in the range of 500 Wh.

How long will a 500 Wh battery last for a recreational rider?

A serious recreational rider can often sustain an average of around 200 watts of leg power for an extended period of time, while a casual rider may average closer to 100 watts. If a rider is providing 200 watts of leg power and the e-bike is set to provide 25% assist, the motor then contributes an additional 50 watts to the wheel (25% of 200 equals 50). A 500 Wh battery could theoretically supply 50 watts for 10 hours.

Although the 10 hour calculation is mathematically true, it is misleading in real world riding where actual range is usually somewhat lower. Why? There are a number of factors. The 200 watts of leg power per hour is an average. There are always spikes in the need for additional watts to cover

All these factors combine to increase energy use.

Higher-end bikes use torque sensors, which adjust assist based on how hard the rider pedals. Lower-cost systems are more likely to use cadence sensors, which simply detect whether the pedals are turning. Torque sensors provide a more natural riding feel. More expensive bikes also often allow riders to finely tune assist levels rather than relying on 3 or 4 fixed factory settings.

Riding and owning an e-bike present additional risks beyond those of conventional bicycles.


Will an E-Bike Reduce Fitness?

This article addresses a common concern among cyclists considering an e-bike: losing their hard-won fitness.

For a pedal-assist e-bike, the answer is generally no. With the motor turned off, an e-bike is simply a heavier bicycle. The rider uses the same muscles, sits in the same position, and pedals with the same mechanics. No matter the level of electric assist, the cardiovascular system primarily responds to the workload generated by the rider’s legs: the watts delivered to the pedals, not to the rear wheel. A given level of perceived exertion, heart rate, or leg power produces a similar training stimulus on either a standard bicycle or an e-bike.

However, electric assist also allows riders to complete rides at much lower exertion levels. If effort is consistently reduced, deconditioning will eventually follow.

Deconditioning can be avoided and fitness improved if


How to Train on an E-Bike

The key to training on an e-bike is to focus on effort rather than road speed. If riders follow this principle, they can train just as effectively on an e-bike as on an unpowered road bike. This means exerting at the same level of perceived exertion or heart rate on both and not forgetting to add in regular interval training. If they do, they will achieve essentially the same level of fitness as if they had trained at the same level of perceived exertion or heart rate on a lightweight road bike.

An example: Suppose you are riding an e-bike set at 25% assist. If you, the cyclist, produce 150 watts at the pedals, the motor adds another 37.5 watts, providing 187 watts at the rear wheel. The rider receives essentially the same training benefit as if the same effort were being produced on a standard bicycle. The e-bike is moving faster because of the additional 37.5 watts supplied by the motor, but the training effect remains tied to the watts being produced by the rider.

This study of experienced mountain bikers found that riders using e-MTBs maintained heart rates at approximately 94% of those achieved on conventional mountain bikes. That level is well within established cardiovascular conditioning ranges.

Maintain

and the physiological training effect remains very similar.

Training on an e-bike can actually offer several advantages over training exclusively on a standard bicycle:

The biggest error when using an e-bike for training is slowly increasing the use of motor assist and avoiding the intended training stress.


How Much Assist Is Really Needed?

How much assist is actually needed in the real world? I’ll use a personal example.

I recently bought a Specialized Creo e-bike. It was just a matter of time until I needed a little boost during my multi-day trips of 50 to 70 miles per day. My question was what power adjustment will make the heavier Creo (35 pounds) equivalent (from my legs’ perspective) to my titanium road bike (20 pounds)?

The Creo allows me to customize three different assist levels. For training I had set level 1 at 10% assist, so when my legs put 150 watts to the pedals, the bike delivers 165 watts to the rear wheel. Was that enough? Too much?

It would make sense that the slope of the road is a major factor as it means I am lifting (over a number of miles) an extra 15 pounds of bike.

I used this calculator to sort it out.

Scenario 1 - flat road 0% grade

Scenario 2 - 2% grade

Scenario 3 - 4% grade

What did I learn? For steady riding at the same speed, the extra 15 pounds of the e-bike does not require as much additional leg power as I expected. On level ground the difference is only a few watts. Even on moderate climbs, the additional steady-state power requirement is modest.

But road riding is not simply maintaining a steady pace. A heavier bike takes more energy to accelerate each time I climb a hill, start from a stop, or speed up to catch another rider. Repeated accelerations make the bike feel heavier and less agile even when the average steady-state wattage difference is modest.

So how much power should I add to my e-bike to get the same training effect as on my lighter road bike? It would seem that 10% (the minimum on a Creo) is more than enough to compensate for the additional weight - if I keep a steady pace. On rolling terrain, an increase to 15% to 20% assist should be enough to compensate for repeated accelerations and short climbs.

I bought my e-bike for the energy reserve (in the battery) available at the end of 50 and 60 mile rides. For short training days, I will just keep the power low and end up working about the same as on my road bike. And for my week long trips or long 50+ training rides, the bike will give me some extra oomph at the end of a longer riding day.


When an E-Bike Makes Sense

E-bikes are particularly useful in these specific riding situations.

I. Getting older (the aging cyclist)

I understand the resistance to e-bikes. I have enjoyed keeping up with my weekend group, knowing that I am doing it all on my own (without electric assist). But as we age, maximal aerobic power falls despite continued training. If riders want to preserve the social enjoyment of group riding, they will either need to find a group that ages along with them or eventually accept the transition to an e-bike.

If you are barely hanging on with your weekend riding group, an e-bike may be the answer. You may get a few comments, but then just point out that their time will come.

II. Multi-day rides

If a cyclist has not put in the training miles, fatigue becomes a significant factor in the day after day riding that comes with:

An e-bike makes these rides far more enjoyable because it reduces the amount of fatigue after a long day on the road.

III. Heart disease

Some riders with cardiac conditions are told by their physician to limit their maximal heart rate. Electric assist can help blunt extreme exertion peaks while still allowing substantial exercise and cardiovascular benefit, providing a safer and more sustainable way to remain physically active. This graph from this blog demonstrates that benefit - note that total exertion over the ride was still 80% of that on an unassisted ride. (Blue line - no assist, Red line - electric assist.)

IV. Couples and mixed abilities

Aside from buying a tandem, e-bikes have done more than any other cycling innovation to keep couples riding together despite different fitness levels. Many riders report that previously reluctant partners now enjoy riding regularly once electric assist becomes available.


E-Bike Maintenance

The additional torque produced by an e-bike places greater strain on the chain and rear cassette. A few tips to reduce wear:

Regular chain lubrication will also help minimize wear. E-bike drivetrains do not allow the rider to rotate the front chainring backwards using the pedals while lubricating the chain, but you don't need a special tool is suggested by this video and article. A simple hex wrench does the trick. These 3 pictures explain it all. My hex wrench didn't exactly fit the chainring bolt, but the hole in the bolt itself let me use a smaller hex to achieve the desired result. Just be careful you don't insert it so far that it scores the motor casing behind the chainring. These three pictures demonstrate the process.

Battery replacement is expensive. Proper care can significantly prolong battery life.

Like phone and laptop batteries, even with ideal care e-bike batteries slowly degrade over time and will need to be replaced. Old batteries should never be discarded in the weekly trash due to:

Use a certified drop-off location instead. If there is no nearby site, contact connect@batterynetwork.org for other options for safe recycling.


E-bike technology is evolving rapidly as modern designs become lighter, quieter, and increasingly similar to traditional bicycles.

The following collection of news items track the evolution of e-bike technology over the last decade. They show e-bikes becoming lighter with ever improving frame geometry. As time passes I suspect we will see even more developments with

2019

2020

2022

2026


E-Bikes and Daily Life

Beyond recreation and fitness, e-bikes are influencing transportation systems and urban planning. These news items highlight how e-bikes are influencing daily life through:

And new applications continue to emerge:

paced athletic training

cargo bikes for groceries as well as delivering kids to school

urban delivery systems

shared transportation

adaptive riding

Articles:

Cities are increasingly subsidizing e-bike purchases because they reduce:

• traffic congestion

• fuel use

• pollution

It’s been speculated that rather than decreasing city congestion, self-driving cars could aggravate the problem. No longer would you sit behind the wheel, get frustrated with the wasted time of commuting, and decide to join a car pool to share the driving. So actually more, rather than fewer, cars would be on the road at any given time. Likewise for Uber and Lyft. They haven't decreased the congestion problem by keeping cars at home. Now they roam the roads waiting for fares, and as a result we actually do have more cars on the roads.

Bet you thought you could get an e-bike and escape into the bike lane, beating those dummies stuck in traffic to work? Well, cyclists now have their own potential bike lane congestion aggravating vehicle - the autonomous food (and packages) delivery robot.

Maybe drones will end up being more cost effective and save us.

CPTIPS e-books covering the exercise physiology and practical nutritional planning to make you a better cyclist.
Powering Performance cover
Ride Longer Ride Stronger cover